Skip Navigation

Comment Spam Review Process

Today's comment spam review process:

  1. delete FROM comments WHERE moderation_required = 1;
  2. Deleted rows: 9699 (Query took 2.0489 sec)

Apologies to anyone whose comment ended up in the moderation queue. I normally keep on top of it, but a couple of weeks of putting it off and what started as a small pile of comments to manage has quickly ballooned into a 10,000 comment monster. Time for a comment spam prevention rethink, I reckon.

8 comments

I wondered why all my comments about a great new poker site, or where to get cheap v1agra (now this comment is definitely getting moderated) never got posted ;)

Might be time to look at a system similar to wp-gatekeeper by Eric Meyer. A captcha system without the accessibility problems of using images. I've been using it for a while now, and while Askimet still has to block some spam messages its not as bad as it could be.

The only problem I have is from actual people submitting comments which *could* be valid but are most likely just looking for a link back. They're always along the lines of 'X is great, thanks for posting about it!'

I know they don't add any additional information to the post, but I don't like to remove them incase it is a genuine show of appreciation, cause that would somehow seem rude(!?)
And of course I don't want to scare people away from telling me how great I am ;)

What I might end up doing is marking those types of comments as 'temp' and then run a cron job or something every week to remove any which are over X days old. Leaving only comments that add additional relevant information in the archive.
Do you use akismet? Since installing it last year I don't get any spam comments (or at least very few)
Aaron: I'm trying really hard to avoid the captcha option :). I'm a little surprised your comment went unmoderated too. Something's not working as it should be! I think, for now, I'm going to add a hidden form field with a generated code. Only comments submitted with valid codes would be accepted - that should curb the automated spam at least.

Cameron: Yes, I'm using akismet. For the most part it catches spam comments, and puts them in the moderation queue, but it's not reliable.
Don't know why you're trying to avoid captcha option. But It really helps prevent automated comments. I think you should give it a send thought.
I avoid the CAPTCHA option because I think making authentic users do more work to compensate for spammers is going about things backwards. I want a system that doesn't affect genuine commenters and makes life harder for spammers.
Dan
Canada #7: May 29, 2007
Dave, I am working on such a system. Perhaps if I get it working, I'll let you know.

If the system works, it should catch 95-98% of spam I reckon.
Your site found in Google: http://google.com/search?q=mjx

Post Your Comment

· Comments with keywords instead of a name have their URLs removed.
· Your email address will not be displayed or shared.

Live Comment Preview

 United States #9: 1 minute ago