Skip Navigation

Mutual Blog Promotion

Launching a new site can be tricky. Unless you have a platform on which to announce your new site (usually an existing popular site), you'll need to go on a campaign of link building. While there are a lot of techniques for this, initially the main technique used by bloggers is to simply comment on other people's blogs, especially those in a similar niche.

This serves to get your name "out there", first and foremost. A lot of people will follow links in blog comments, so regardless of whether "nofollow" is in use on a blog, any comment has some inherent value. There is also a fair chance that a blogger will follow the links of the people that comment on their blog - and if they are in a similar niche, they may link to your blog.

That is where things start to get interesting. If you have link-worthy content, you still need people to see it in order for them to be aware it is there, and good enough to link to (this can be another problem with launching a blog - some of your best content may be posted at the start, when you have no readers and therefore not get nearly the attention it deserves).

Comments are the quickest way to get that exposure. The more you comment on other blogs, the more likely people are to find yours and link to your content.

A comment is also essentially a tiny taster of your own site. Many people's first impression of you and your site is your comments - making a good impression with your comments is incredibly important.

Comments also add value to the commentee's blog. Visitors like to read comments, and they like to see activity on a blog. It adds a sense of community to what otherwise can seem like little more than a soapbox. And good content deserves comments - a lack of comments, conversely, can indicate poor quality content.

This makes bloggers who visit the blogs of their commenters, and comment in turn on those blogs, extremely valuable. These are the people who create a good impression for their visitors. They are complimenting their commenters - saying "your comment made me want to find out more about you".

And in turn, while these people are out commenting on their commenter's blogs, they are finding content to link to (it seems to me that the most prolific return-commenters often link to some of the freshest and most difficult to find content out there).

All of this in turn brings me on to how I apply this to marketing a website or blog: I keep a list of the people in each niche I work in who "return" comments. If I'm marketing a new website, I use that list as the basis for any commenting work (on that subject: all commenting work I do is strictly white-hat - genuine, considered comments all the way, no keywords in the "name" field and no spam - quality not quantity).

My list serves as a sort of white-list. If I'm going to spend time commenting on blogs, and by doing so increase the exposure of a site, I want two things:

  1. I want high value "tasters" out there - I want people who see a comment as an intelligent response to an article (which it should always be), not a boilerplate or automated SEO-comment.
  2. I want to spend time commenting on sites run by people who are known to visit the sites of their commenters and engage with those people and sites.

Essentially, this means that site launches are now relatively simple affairs. I can spend more time writing better comments on the sites that I know I'll get the best return from. I can safely ignore nofollow (because commenting can be about exposure, not SEO). I can avoid commenting on the sites of people who do fire-and-forget blogging (where they post and then ignore the post, never responding to comments or visiting the sites of their commenters).

Best of all, it is really enjoyable work - rather than trying to generate a massive number of links for SEO purposes with generic thoughtless garbage comments, I can justify spending quality time on a site, getting to know the author from their work, and engaging with them in a very real way - better for them, and better for me.

33 comments

Los Angeles Search Engine Optimization
Unknown #1: June 30, 2007
Well said my friend! I promoted a programming blog before just by comments, and that make it much more popular. It is very useful way to gain traffic and exposure.
Awesome. I mention 'no keywords in the "name" field' in the article, and what does the first person commenting do? Yup, use the "name" field for SEO. Your URL has been removed, of course, Mr. Los Angeles Search Engine Optimization.
Interesting article. haven't thought about that.. but then again. i don't blog. (my website isn't even finished yet)

Quite funny thought that the first person commenting ignores the article.
Ah, the irony...

Enjoyable article. I can't say I've been anything like that systematic in identifying "those who respond," but I definitely do find myself with some similar category dividers in my head...
Sometimes I search for pages with high page rank and comment on them.
Usually, .gov, .org and .edu sites powered by wordpress is pretty good.
Well said!

While I do work hard on the strategic part of blog promoting, I also like to see the blogosphere with the somehow romantic eyes that is a huge conversation among many many people.

Is like a giantic and very long party when you go here and there on different groups and discuss things.

Leaving valuable, white-hat comments on other people's blogs is like joining a conversation group on a party and make clever statements. Black-hat comments are just like someone joining your groups just interrupt and give his visit card.

Great article!
To be very honest, i have formFiller extension that fills my form that did that.
Excellent points.

People get so focused on the quantity of links they submit that they ignore the quality. If everyone were to comment on-topic, in a way that benefits the community reading the blog, they would find that they serve both the community and their own marketing goals. As with so many other Web marketing strategies, it all comes down to content.

I am constantly irked by the folks trying to sell off-topic product X on my Web Development blog. Naturally I delete them. But when someone posts something relevant, I not only approve the comment, but I also follow the link, and in many cases end up subscribing to that person's blog as well.

Mgccl's suggestion to comment on highly ranked sites is fine if those sites are topically relevant, but if they're not, then neither Mgccl or the readers of those blogs is well served.

If a million sites link to you, but none of them are related to your site's subject matter, then perhaps you'll get a good search ranking, but you won't be getting any traffic from those links. People forget that not all traffic comes from search engines, and as with any other form of marketing, word of mouth, in this case through links on trusted sites, is often most powerful.
I completely agree with this article as well. I enabled "dofollow" for my comment links because I feel is someone takes the time to write a worth-while comment, they should get the link-love for it.

I do, however, nofollow all links inside a comment so a user can't come along and just post 3 or 4 links inside a worth while comment.
@Jonathan - That seems a nice strategy. I am willing to enable dofollow for the commenter's URL, because I do agree with you that anyone who properly contributes a worth-while comment to your blog deserves the link love.

But, as things actually are, I am a little bit concerned about having to moderate and delete too many opportunist non-worth-while comments on a regular basis.

I came across the Wordpress <a href="http://www.allpassionmarketing.com/software.html#linklove">Linklove plugin</a> that disables nofollow for commenters that have commented a certain number of times, like a reward for regular comenters.

This may be an interesting step, but still is not the ideal, IMHO. I'd like to just enable undiscriminate dofollow for commenters without gathering and excess of oportunism.
Launching a new site is easy, but promoting it is what makes it tricky. I'm no SEO expert, but try to follow white-hat techniques to promote a few websites that I run. I came to your site a several months ago when I was looking for cheat sheets. I liked your cheat sheets so much, that I've added them to my collection.

I agree with you on building great contents that are worthwhile for others to link and also comment on. I found this article to be useful, so I decided to comment on it. I used to suffer from spam comments on my Wordpress blogs in early days of web experience. There are too many evils out there cluttering up the blogs with spam contents. On the other hand, there are even more good people making the web worthwhile place to hang out.
If you pay attention to others and what they're posting on their blogs then there's a good chance that they're going to notice you and post and help promote your blog, as well. It's a mutual thing.
 United Kingdom #13: July 22, 2007
I agree with you that quality should always come before quantity, both in comments and posts.
I must admit that it can be tempting to leave comments on every site you find when first starting out, but over time you realise that it's the comments with some thought behind them that are the most satisfying.
Heidi makes a good point about not all traffic coming from search engines. I was told about this site through word of mouth by a work colleague (I must say it's a great resource for cheatsheets in case you haven't heard that enough! hehe).

I'm still new to the blog scene (in terms of setting my own one up) and read some similar posts to this one on other blogs. I had no idea what the nofollow/dofollow stuff was about until I figured it out reading this post. I assume it's a wordpress thing?

Anyways, I'm learning as I go and making my through your marketing posts which hold some great knowledge!
It's funny, actually, to think how people blitz the Internet with pointless posts about crap they want to sell. Those tend to remind me that they are just using print marketing techniques over web marketing. When in reality they are two entirely different beasts.

Blogs are no different. They are intended for very specific markets and very specific people. And when someone comes in and throws in a link that is obviously intended to go to something so incredibly random and off topic, it only serves to make the people reading bitter towards the brand that is being promoted, and it gets you banned from the blog you tried to post on anyways. When will they ever figure that out?

How long until people realize that if you want to be found on the Internet, just offer some quality content to things that request it, or just go pay a lot of money in PPC? ;-)

Posts without content will only be a link back to your page...and if you get some negligible result in SEO for that link, it will quickly be negated when people start to realize that all the links back to your pages will only follow through to empty content anyway and ultimately leave a negative taste in their mouth(s).

Nice post! Loved it.
Awesome post, exactly the kinda thing I've been finding holds true. I feel I've now gotta post something constructive in light of what you've just said - but I don't think there's much more to say!

Forwarding this to my Marketing Manager!
Excellent post! It really helps to improve your traffic and PR too if you post to blogs where No follow tag is not being used.
Dofollow isn't necessarily always the best option for your blog depending on your content and focus, but I do believe that in _most_ instances the benefits outweigh the detractions.
Its ironic that many bloggers talk about this but then they actually use no follow.
Absolutely. I found this post while researching counter arguments to SEO. I have a link placed in a forum in December 1995 that still produces visits. It's not exactly a blog comment but I'd bet a few of your comments will still be working for you in 2017 and beyond.
actually, blog commenting is way better than submitting to directories when promoting a site.
I think is a good method... if you write good comments.
 Russian Federation #23: January 6, 2008
Thank you VERY much! It is a good method!
Any fresh ideas on how to network in a subject category filled with bloggers who jealously guard their turf? It’s a revelation to me whenever I hear stories of bloggers supporting one another because so far that has not been my experience with bloggers in my category.

I recently launched a blog and I sent out simple, low-key introductory emails to a few of the already-established blogs in my topic area which is related to learning a foreign language. The reception has been lukewarm to cold. One blogger removed a link to my blog from my comments, even though it was on topic and even though I had been posting comments on his blog for six months before I ever put a link to my blog on his. Funny, I would’ve thought that after SIX MONTHS of posting comments on his blog, without ever asking for anything in return, I would’ve been entitled to put a measly link to my blog in one of my comments. When asked about this, he told me flat out that he viewed my blog as “a commercial enterprise”. In other words, he views my blog as competition, competition which he does not wish to aid in any way.
Good info, yes this commenting on other blogs is a fine and effective method of blog promotion. Search engines art king in the world of promotion but commenting can be a very worthwhile activity. But it can be time-consuming.
If you have crap content no one will link to you. I think you hit the nail on the head with this one. By the way I love Jack Daniels too, but boy does he hate me.
I build up one way links with ezine articles. As long as the article in of good quality, and i continue the process of link building it works fine for me.
Landing Mats
United States #28: April 10, 2008
This was a great post. These suggestions on commenting and launching a site are really useful. Thanks!
I think it is a great idea to help drive sales for the 2 sites. i think articles are another great method.
Excellent post, as always. I love your blog, really useful content, not to mention fantastic cheat sheets! :o)

Thank you!

Kate Anderson
Excellent article and a truly amazing blog - I have subscribed!
your post is great..nobody has visited me from my comments.i get visitors from search engines..
I agree with you that quality should always come before quantity, both in comments and posts.
I must admit that it can be tempting to leave comments on every site you find when first starting out, but over time you realise that it's the comments with some thought behind them that are the most satisfying.

Post Your Comment

· Comments with keywords instead of a name have their URLs removed.
· Your email address will not be displayed or shared.

Live Comment Preview

 United States #34: 1 minute ago